I have my setting for pop up on PM's and notify me of PM's...

Neather of which are occouring. Courious if this is the case for anyone else too?

Is it a setting I am missing or the way the board is set?

Hrm... that's odd. I know I saw it some time ago in the admin area and it was set to pop up. I remember because I like it that way too. However going back to make sure it is still set that way, I cant find it.

To make sure its not your end check all your pop up blockers. You may have one turned off, but another may still be catching it. I will continue to search...